by danso on 7/24/25, 7:36 PM with 3 comments
by uolmir on 7/24/25, 7:48 PM
In short, the authors and NASA strongly disagree with the decision to retract and argue that this is clearly outside of the typical norms for what retraction is supposed to represent. A paper being wrong isn't and shouldn't be the standard for retraction, particularly in this case when the original paper was published with multiple technical responses and rejoinders.